Colonial Penn $9.95 Life Insurance Review – Scam Revealed!

You’ve seen the Colonial Penn $ 9.95 commercials with the famous pitchman who smiles and says, “Just $9.95 a month!” It sounds so simple when they say they offer Affordable coverage, no health questions, and guaranteed acceptance.

But many seniors say that the Colonial Penn $9.95 plan is perhaps the most misleading life insurance offer in America.

In this article, I’ll break down exactly how Colonial Penn’s $9.95 plan works against you, how much coverage you can actually get for $9.95, and why so many people feel cheated after signing up.

I’ll also show you what better alternatives exist, plans that actually start on day one, with real coverage and transparent pricing.

---

WHAT IS COLONIAL PENN’S $9.95 LIFE INSURANCE PLAN?

Colonial Penn’s $9.95 plan is a guaranteed-acceptance whole life policy sold by Colonial Penn Life Insurance Company, a subsidiary of CNO Financial Group.

The company has been around for decades and markets heavily to seniors through television commercials featuring familiar faces and comforting music.

The ad sounds simple because they offer life insurance for only $9.95 a month, guaranteed acceptance, and no health questions. But what they don’t emphasize is that $9.95 only buys one “unit” of coverage. It’s not a full policy. It’s only a partial policy for about 99.9% of seniors.

Each “unit” equals a small amount of death benefit, usually between $400 and $1,500, depending on your age and gender.

The older you are, the smaller your benefit per unit. You can buy multiple units, but each one costs another $9.95.

For someone who needs $10,000 in protection, the real price could be $60 to $120 per month, not $9.95. Even over $200 a month is not uncommon.

It’s also important to know that this plan is guaranteed issue, which means the company doesn’t ask health questions. Everyone gets approved if they can afford the outlandish prices Colonial Penn charges.

Because Colonial Penn accepts everyone, they protect themselves with a two-year waiting period.

If you pass away from natural causes during the first two years, your family doesn’t get the full benefit. They only get a refund of what you paid so far, plus a small amount of interest.

This structure protects the company, not you as a customer. It’s the tradeoff you make when you buy guaranteed acceptance life insurance instead of qualifying for massively better first-day coverage.

Remember: I’ve reviewed hundreds of these policies for families who thought they were protected. They weren’t.

---

HOW MUCH COVERAGE DO YOU REALLY GET FOR $9.95?

The answer depends on your age and gender. But for most people, the coverage per unit is stupidly small.
According to Colonial Penn’s official rate chart, here’s exactly what one $9.95 unit buys:

That means a 75-year-old man paying Colonial Penn $9.95 a month only has about $550 in life insurance. To reach $10,000 in coverage, he’d need 18 units, which would cost $179.10 per month.

Compare that to most first-day-coverage final expense plans, where a healthy 75-year-old woman might pay $71 per month for a $10,000 policy that pays immediately, not after two years.

The difference isn’t small, it’s massive. You’re paying more, waiting longer, and getting less coverage.

Colonial Penn’s $9.95 plan was designed for people with serious health conditions who can’t qualify anywhere else. But most applicants can.

About 97% of people I talk with still qualify for first-day coverage from the top-rated carriers used by the Final Expense Guy.

Remember: Most callers think $9.95 means $9.95 total. The company knows that. That’s why this plan keeps selling to unsuspecting seniors.

---

DOES COLONIAL PENN HAVE A WAITING PERIOD?

Yes, every Colonial Penn $9.95 policy comes with a MANDATORY two-year waiting period.

That means if you pass away from natural causes within the first 24 months, your loved ones will not receive the full death benefit. Instead, Colonial Penn refunds the premiums you’ve paid, plus a small amount of interest at 7% total.

That’s the tradeoff when a company promises “guaranteed acceptance.” They can’t ask about your health, so they protect their bottom line by delaying when your coverage actually starts.

During those two years, only accidental deaths, like a car accident or a fall, would pay the full benefit. Any other cause, including a heart attack, cancer, or stroke, would not.

This is the single most misunderstood part of the Colonial Penn $9.95 offer. The ads never clearly say, “There’s a two-year waiting period before your coverage pays out.” They focus on comforting words like “peace of mind” and “guaranteed acceptance,” which sound safe but hide a terribly 2-year wait plan.

Guaranteed-issue life insurance like Colonial Penn’s should never be an option that you would consider.

#1 – You probably qualify for 1st-day coverage through another company.
#2 – If guaranteed issue is your only choice, there are other companies with massively lower pricing and between 10-30% refund of premium interest rates.

Remember: I always tell families, a waiting period is not protection; it’s a delay that could cost you big time if life does not go as planned. Real peace of mind starts when your policy pays from day one.

---

COLONIAL PENN BACKGROUND & FINANCIAL RATINGS

Colonial Penn Life Insurance Company was founded in 1968 and is based in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.

It’s owned by CNO Financial Group, the same parent company that owns Bankers Life and Washington National.

Financially, Colonial Penn is stable enough to meet its obligations. According to A.M. Best, it holds an A (Excellent) financial strength rating, which is average.

While that’s not a red flag, it’s also not the strongest rating among major insurers. For comparison, companies like Mutual of Omaha and Aetna typically carry A- or A+ ratings.

The Better Business Bureau (BBB) gives Colonial Penn an A+ rating, but that score reflects how they respond to complaints, not how satisfied customers are.

In fact, there are hundreds of complaints filed with the BBB and the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC), many about misleading marketing, poor communication, or confusion about coverage amounts.

Colonial Penn has been in business for more than 50 years, but its marketing hasn’t evolved with transparency…many seniors would say this is intentional.

Remember: Just because a company has been around a long time doesn’t mean it’s the best option for you.

---

COLONIAL PENN COMPLAINTS AND CONSUMER REVIEWS

Colonial Penn delivers what it promises, but what it promises is far less than most buyers think or are informed they’re getting.

On the Better Business Bureau (BBB) site, you’ll find thousands of reviews and complaints mentioning the same pattern: seniors believe they’re buying a full life insurance policy for $9.95, only to discover it buys one “unit” of coverage worth a few hundred dollars.

Others report that their claims were delayed or denied because the death occurred during the two-year waiting period.

Many families also describe frustrating customer service experiences. Calls can take hours, paperwork often requires mailing physical forms, and cancellation or policy adjustments can be slow.

On Trustpilot, Colonial Penn’s rating sits below most major insurers, with recurring themes of misleading advertising, poor communication, and unclear benefit explanations.

The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) also shows Colonial Penn with a complaint index higher than the industry average. That means the company receives more complaints relative to its size than most competitors.

Remember: I’ve reviewed dozens of Colonial Penn policies where the family thought they had $10,000 of protection. It was barely $1,000.

---

WHO IS THE COLONIAL PENN $9.95 PLAN GOOD FOR?

This plan only makes sense for only one type of person: someone who truly cannot qualify for any other form of life insurance.

Even at that, you’re better off going with other companies that the Final Expense Guy can refer you to.

If you’ve been declined multiple times due to advanced illness, such as terminal cancer, late-stage heart disease, or oxygen dependency, then Colonial Penn’s guaranteed-issue plan could work…if it weren’t so overpriced.

For everyone else, it’s usually a bad deal. Most people over age 50 can qualify for simplified-issue whole life insurance with first-day coverage, no medical exam, and just a few basic health questions. Those plans cost less per dollar of coverage, have higher benefits, and start paying immediately.

The difference can be dramatic. For example, a 65-year-old woman with mild health conditions could pay $41 per month for a $10,000 first-day coverage policy from a top-rated carrier like Trinity Life or Family Benefit Life. The same amount of coverage through Colonial Penn would cost around $79.60 – and still include a two-year waiting period.

Colonial Penn markets heavily to seniors on fixed incomes, but it’s those same families who end up paying more and receiving less.

Remember: About 97% of the people I help qualify for immediate coverage with no waiting period. You probably can too.

---

BETTER ALTERNATIVES TO COLONIAL PENN

There are far stronger options for people looking for affordable burial or final expense coverage that starts immediately.

The key difference is choosing simplified-issue whole life insurance instead of guaranteed-issue coverage.

Simplified-issue means you’ll have to answer a few short health questions. There is no medical exam, and decisions are made instantly. These plans pay from the very first day, not two years later. They are backed by financially strong, A-rated carriers that specialize in final expense coverage for seniors. And you’re rewarded with massively lower pricing.

Companies such as Trinity Life, Family Benefit Life, Aetna, and other companies consistently offer better value, stronger benefits, and faster payouts. These are the policies I recommend to my own clients.

Here’s a clear comparison of what real alternatives look like:

When you look at it this way, the difference is obvious.

First-day coverage plans offer stronger protection at nearly half the cost. And the money your family receives is guaranteed to pay out immediately, without fine print or delays.

Remember: Real protection starts the day you qualify, not years later.

---

HOW TO COMPARE FINAL EXPENSE POLICIES PROPERLY

Many people compare life insurance the wrong way. They look at the monthly price without understanding what they are actually buying.

To compare correctly, focus on four key points:

1. When the coverage starts: If the policy includes words like “graded,” “modified,” or “return of premium,” it means there is a waiting period. Always ask if your coverage pays immediately.
2. The stability of your premium: A proper whole life policy never increases in cost. If your quote says the price can go up, it is the wrong product.
3. The total benefit amount: Always look at the payout your family will actually receive. A cheap policy with a small benefit is not real protection.
4. The strength of the company: Check the A.M. Best rating before buying. Stick with insurers rated A or better.

Working with an independent broker means you see multiple carriers side by side. That’s how you know you’re getting both the best rate and the right type of coverage.

Remember: The right comparison could save you thousands and guarantee your family’s payout arrives when they need it most.

---

FINAL VERDICT – IS COLONIAL PENN $9.95 A SCAM?

It is not a scam in the legal sense, but it is misleading in how it is advertised.

The Colonial Penn $9.95 offer hooks seniors with emotional messaging, then quietly delivers minimal coverage with a two-year waiting period.

The company relies on misleading television marketing, and the numbers simply don’t justify the overpriced rates. Paying $150-$200 a month for $10,000 of coverage that takes two years to activate is not a good deal.

For most people, there are far better options from the Final Expense Guy. Simplified-issue whole life policies from financially strong companies provide immediate benefits, lower premiums, and guaranteed lifetime coverage.

Remember: I help families every day replace policies like these with plans that actually protect them from day one. If you want real coverage, call 888-862-9456 or visit FEXGUY.com to compare your best first-day coverage options.

---

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

Is Colonial Penn life insurance legitimate?

Yes. Colonial Penn is a legitimate insurance company owned by CNO Financial Group. The issue is not legitimacy; it is value. Their guaranteed-acceptance plan is legally sound but financially weak compared to what most people can qualify for.

What does “unit” mean in the Colonial Penn $9.95 plan?

A “unit” is a small block of coverage that changes based on your age and gender. One unit usually equals $400 to $1,500 in benefit. The older you are, the less coverage you get per unit.

Does Colonial Penn have a waiting period?

Yes. Every guaranteed-acceptance policy from Colonial Penn includes a two-year waiting period for natural causes. During that time, your family only receives the premiums you paid plus a small interest amount.

Can I get first-day coverage instead?

Most people can. If you can answer a few basic health questions and are not in critical condition, you likely qualify for simplified-issue whole life insurance that starts immediately.

How much coverage will $9.95 buy at age 65 or 75?

At age 65, one unit provides about $1,000 in coverage. At age 75, it drops closer to $560 for men and $680 for women. To reach a typical $10,000 benefit, the monthly cost is often well over $100.

What happens if I die within two years?

Your family receives a refund of premiums plus interest, not the full benefit. The only exception is if the death was accidental.

Does Colonial Penn offer coverage for veterans?

Colonial Penn is a private insurer, not a veterans’ program. Veterans are often better served through companies used at the Final Expense Guy.

Is Colonial Penn good for burial insurance?

No. True burial insurance should pay immediately so funeral expenses are covered on time. Colonial Penn’s two-year delay defeats that purpose.

Can I cancel and get a refund?

You can cancel at any time, but you’ll only receive a refund of unearned premiums, not the full amount you paid over time.

What are the best alternatives?

Simplified-issue whole life policies from companies like Family Benefit Life, Trinity, and Prosperity Life typically offer better rates, first-day benefits, and stronger financial ratings.

Remember: I’ve compared every major carrier in the market. In nearly every case, first-day coverage costs less and pays more than Colonial Penn’s guaranteed plan.

---